Sunday, April 15, 2007

The Namesake

Genre: Drama
Director: Mira Nair
Cast: Tabu, Irrfan Khan, Kal Penn, Jacinda Barrett, Zuleikha Robinson
Storyline: About struggling to find your identity before it slips through the cracks of two alien cultures that define your existence
Bottomline: Impressive performances in a story well told



A great thing about Jhumpa Lahiri is her perceptiveness and maturity while defining relationships. And the great thing about Mira Nair is her perceptiveness about identity.
In `The Namesake,' the skills of these two women come together to tell a tale that makes for compelling viewing.
If you can forget the discrepancy of `Vanity Fair,' you will find this movie an intelligent match to Nair's critically acclaimed `Monsoon Wedding.'

Nicely moulded
The film, based on a novel of the same name by Lahiri, follows Ashoke Ganguli (Irrfan, Bengali accent authentically in place) and his bride Ashima (Tabu) to their new home in America. As strangers legally bound to a life together, they are trying to fit in with each other as much as they are with their new country.
The development of the relationship is moulded nicely, and the film moves at a languorous pace as the Gangulis warm to each other in awkward fits and starts. It is in the foreign country that their family grows.
Gogol (Kal Penn), their son, significantly named after the Russian author who inadvertently saved his father's life, not only has to deal with his Indian heritage but his unusual name.
In `The Namesake,' the director acknowledges that people don't always live by their stereotypes. So many British Indian films about the Indian cultural identity in a foreign land, find their conflict because the older generation refuses to adapt to the new, and the younger generation doesn't understand the old.
This is true to some extent over here, as Ashima disapprovingly notices her son's white girlfriend caress him and is shocked when the girl calls her by her name, instead of the infinitely more respectful `aunty.' But the thing is, she attempts to cover up to make the children feel comfortable.
Another stereotype is turned on its head when Gogol finds that his good Indian girl refuses to take his name, has a life of her own, and appears to have had a lot more lovers than he.
The screenplay by Sooni Taraporevala is sentimental without being cloying, and funny without being cheesy. The problem is that as the film progresses, the narrative picks up speed, like it has suddenly realised that it is running out of time.
This is always an issue when a film has been adapted from a novel - usually resolved by taking liberties with the plot.
But this plot is life, so the compromise is that later on in the film, the development is comparatively sketchy.
`The Namesake' is about finding roots, `know where you come from to get where you're going.' Interestingly, Kal is listed as Kalpen Modi, his original Indian name in the credits.
The best part of Nair's latest offering is that it manages to be moving and emotional without sinking into melodrama.
Watch out for a cameo by Jhumpa Lahiri.

11 comments:

Wishnew said...

I tried to catch a screening the week it was released here and apparently, so did the rest of world, judging from the long lines outside Paris Theatre (where 'Water' also was screened). Things didn't work out that time.

You review is the necessary kick in the butt I desperately need. I'll write you back once I see it for myself.

Anonymous said...

never thought anything of mira nair. but after seeing susan's wonderful writeup felt compelled to watch it. i did. thanks susan. keep writing...

Unknown said...

uve put together everything a movie goer need to knw to decide about the movie. will get bck to u after i see the film.

Sandhya Menon said...

You know how much I like your writing, Susan. And it never fails to surprise me, this knack you have for cinema - perhaps because I have none. Having said that, I find this review a rather nice departure from your usual style and depth. You've gone a little deeper, treated it with the gravity that the film requires at the same time not going overboard with opinion. I like.
I have issues with the syntax in certain sentences but I am just finicky and they are subtle enough so that you'll mostly miss them.
I love that you sum up beautifully the intellectualities (sorry for making that word up) of it as a film but I am not sure how you responded to the film. I'd like to know that - did you or did you not like the film on a purely response basis, as opposed to thoughtout and analysed opinion. THat is not to say that I don't enjoy the latter, but I'd like to know the former too!
:) Thanks for this though. And I liked the previous post on KG too!
Sandhya

Anonymous said...

hey susan...
Had my doubts about a good novel being adapted into a good movie. Had fewer doubts though, about that good movie earning itself a good (read well-written) review from Miss Muthalaly :) Nicely analysed, as always. Haven't watched this (acclaimed) film, but like i said, will take Su's review as the cue. Thats me heading reverse - the review first, movie next, book third !!!! Two layman-posers: 1. Why is it titled The Namesake (haven't read the book, as you would've guessed). 2. How's Tabu in the film ?

Susan Muthalaly said...

Vishnu, RK, Lakshmi,Sandy, Shivani...
Thank you for the kind words.
Sandhya, I did like the film. Very much.
Shivani, Namesake because a lot of the story takes off on Gogol being named after the Russian author. Tabu is good. I liked Irrfan a lot too. And thanks for making my day. again :)

Anonymous said...

exaggerated

ng

Houseowner said...

now i will buy DVD from C.N.Ramesh to watch movie! :)

cheers!
ramya

Sapna Anu B.George said...

Nise to meet you in your orkut and blog.I find your review very well written,not"exajurated" me. Reviewd well and explained too.

Anonymous said...

wonderful movie and a great review.But at times it strikes me..why do we need to sympthise with these folks whose mantra is "home is where money is".

The magic of the movie lies in the apt casting..Irfan rocks..there were rumours of Abhi bachan being considered for kal's role..thank heavens!!

Swahilya Shambhavi said...

Hi Susan, Nice reading your blog.